Papa Nick’s is lovingly named after owner, Sebastian Tauriello’s father Nick, the family patriarch. Working in his fathers pizzeria at the ripe old age of 13, Sebastian would help out in the kitchen doing everything from stirring sauces to tossing dough. It was that experience that would lead Sebastian to play an integral part of running the family business & rolodex his parents authentic Italian recipes to continue the family tradition. Everything from the fresh pizza dough to the made-from-scratch meatballs are products of his mom & dads handiwork. Today the entire Tauriello family makes Papa Nick’s what it is, an independent Italian pizzeria offering quality dishes they are proud to offer your family.
We welcome you to stop by & enjoy the great taste of authentic Italian-American food.
The Tauriello Family
Family owned, pizza was fresh, hot and had a lot of flavor. Great selection and variety of pies… Will definitely be back.
Always great tasting pizza… No matter the selection! I choose to get a grilled chicken slice, cold to go… Pop it in the toaster oven and… A little slice of heaven right here on earth!
This place is great! The slices are huge and they have many to choose from. This is the definition of great New York pizza! I hope you guys will be in business for many years to come! I’ve loved everything I’ve tried and the staff are all super nice.
Probably one of the best pizza spots I’ve been too out east long island. Pizza tastes so fresh and cooked to brilliancy. I use to come here as a middle schooler after school with me and my friends. Everyone was always kind and respectful. The zeppoles are absolutely amazing and they aren’t stingy with the powdered sugar either like most places!
Very good pizza!! Love the crispy crust! Great specialty pizzas, especially the salad pizza. Excellent calzones too.
I grew up in Bellport and still have yet to find any pizza that beats this place. Great pizza and staff.
Contact us today to enjoy our finest, homemade Italian cuisines.